Understanding Advertising · 7 min read
Why Consistent Advertising Works
Building recognition over time without wasting impressions.
Advertising is not only for today's buyer
Many B2B products are purchased infrequently. A travel agent may consider a new supplier only when a particular enquiry arrives; an importer may revisit logistics partners when a route becomes unreliable. A campaign that is judged entirely on today's enquiries can overlook the value of being remembered later.
John Dawes's work on B2B buying cycles suggests advertisers should consider the much larger group of prospective buyers who are not currently purchasing. That is not permission to ignore leads. It is a reason to distinguish building future demand from capturing current demand and to measure those jobs differently.
Further reading: Ehrenberg-Bass Institute / LinkedIn B2B Institute · LinkedIn B2B Institute / IPA
What consistency actually means
Consistency is not the same as repeating the exact artwork indefinitely. It means repeating recognisable brand elements and a coherent promise: the name, colours, visual cues, tone, category and useful customer benefit. The execution can adapt while the brand remains easy to identify.
IPA and System1 research into creative consistency found that brands with more consistent creative approaches were associated with stronger brand and business effects in its sample. These results are encouraging, but the study is not a test of optimal frequency for South African trade media.
Further reading: IPA / System1
The audience needs to encounter the message
Advertising frequency is the number of opportunities an individual has to see a message; reach is the number of different people with that opportunity. An advertiser can book a long run yet still reach too narrow a group, or spread exposure so thinly that recognition struggles to develop.
A sensible media plan asks who needs to be reached, where they regularly consume industry information, which formats are available and how long the campaign must remain relevant. A newsletter and a website placement may complement one another, but their audiences may overlap. Do not simply add each channel's figures together.
The creative must earn its repetition
More repetitions of an unclear advertisement do not solve an unclear proposition. If someone cannot tell what the advertiser offers, who it is for or which brand is responsible, repetition may simply repeat the confusion.
Research on advertising creativity and wear-out indicates that original, relevant creative can respond differently to repeated exposure than weaker work. This supports improving the advertisement before deciding that it needs more insertions.
Further reading: Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science / Monash University
A practical campaign review
Write one clear campaign goal, one primary buying situation and one message. Choose formats that reach the intended professional audience; set a realistic duration; retain recognisable branding; and review the performance of each placement against its purpose.
For example, a freight software supplier could maintain a recognisable brand campaign while rotating messages about documentation, visibility and compliance. The objective is to strengthen a connected series of relevant associations rather than run a disconnected succession of promotions.
Sources and further reading
These sources inform the article. Academic studies, commissioned industry research and professional ethics guidance are different forms of evidence. Results from consumer media or other markets should not be assumed to describe South African B2B audiences.
- Advertising Effectiveness and the 95-5 Rule (2021)
Ehrenberg-Bass Institute / LinkedIn B2B Institute — John Dawes; an illustration of long buying cycles for many B2B categories, not a universal exact percentage.
- The Five Principles of Growth in B2B Marketing (2019)
LinkedIn B2B Institute / IPA — Effectiveness research about long- and short-term B2B marketing.
- How Creative Consistency Strengthens Brands and Business Effects (2024)
IPA / System1 — Industry effectiveness analysis of over 4,000 ads; associations, not a universal causal rule.
- The Effects of Creativity on Advertising Wear-In and Wear-Out (2016)
Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science / Monash University — Chen, Yang and Smith; experimental study of creativity and repetition.
