Skip to content

Better Advertising Practice · 7 min read

When Should You Change Your Advertisement?

How to refresh a campaign without throwing away recognition.

Now Media Marketing Resources · Research-informed practical guidance

A change is not automatically an improvement

Advertisers often ask how frequently they should supply new artwork. That sounds like a production question, but it is primarily a communication question. Is the current idea clear, relevant, recognisable and still accurate? Changing the layout for novelty can sacrifice familiarity without adding anything useful.

A good advertisement can improve as more of the intended audience encounter it, especially when the idea and the brand are linked. This does not mean an advert should run forever. It means the case for change should be based on a real reason.

What the research suggests

The IPA and System1 analysed thousands of advertisements and found stronger creative consistency associated with stronger brand effects and some business outcomes. In a separate experimental study, Chen, Yang and Smith investigated creativity and advertising wear-in and wear-out. Their work suggests the quality and relevance of an idea influence its response to repetition.

Neither study provides a simple rule such as replace every fourth insertion. The evidence comes from particular samples and media settings. It is a useful reason to preserve valuable brand assets and test changes deliberately.

Further reading: IPA / System1 · Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science / Monash University

Five sensible reasons to refresh

Change an advertisement when product information or pricing is out of date; when a seasonal or promotional message has ended; when the audience has a new problem; when the creative is difficult to read on the placement; or when campaign evidence suggests the current execution is not doing the job.

Also consider the advertiser's sales priorities. A supplier may need to switch the featured product while keeping the campaign's brand promise. An inaccurate advertisement should be corrected immediately, regardless of how recently it was designed.

Refresh the execution before abandoning the platform

Start with small, purposeful changes: a more useful image, a clearer headline, a different application, a proof point, a relevant offer or a stronger call to action. Retain the logo, colours, typography and other distinctive cues so that earlier exposures support later ones.

If the central proposition is weak, a more fundamental creative change may be justified. Do not confuse consistency with protecting an ineffective concept. A/B testing can help with immediate response, but a single test of click rates is not a full measure of long-term brand effects.

A review checklist for trade advertisers

Ask what the advertisement is trying to communicate; whether the brand is identifiable in one glance; whether the offer remains accurate; whether the message still fits the intended audience; and whether the reader can take the next step easily.

Review mobile and desktop renderings, not just the design file. Keep a record of which version ran and when. Where practicable, compare response measures across variations while recognising the limits of small sample sizes and overlapping audience exposures.

Sources and further reading

These sources inform the article. Academic studies, commissioned industry research and professional ethics guidance are different forms of evidence. Results from consumer media or other markets should not be assumed to describe South African B2B audiences.

  1. How Creative Consistency Strengthens Brands and Business Effects (2024)

    IPA / System1 — Industry effectiveness analysis of over 4,000 ads; associations, not a universal causal rule.

  2. The Effects of Creativity on Advertising Wear-In and Wear-Out (2016)

    Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science / Monash University — Chen, Yang and Smith; experimental study of creativity and repetition.

  3. Erik du Plessis, The Advertised Mind (2005; later edition 2008)

    Kogan Page — Influential book on emotion, memory, recall and brand linkage; some evidence based on television advertisements.